Gem Motel (Demolished)
Gem, IN Photo courtesy Emily Steele
The sparkle had faded at Gem Motel in Gem, Indiana, by the time this view was taken. Along old U.S. 40, the worn little property still offered something worth noticing. Even in its later years, it recalled the days when independent motor courts were familiar stops along the National Road.
Historic postcards advertised kitchenettes, a handy feature for families staying more than one night. The motel served the postwar highway trade, but Interstate 70 eventually carried much of that traffic away. Like other small lodging stops along the old road, Gem faced a quieter future.
UPDATE: Gem Motel has been demolished, and its roadside sign is gone. Little remains at the site to suggest that travelers once pulled in here for the night. Another modest motor court has disappeared from the National Road. 07-26
40 Motel
Columbus, OH Photo courtesy Dirk Burhans
The 40 Motel has one of the biggest roadside signs in Columbus. Its towering marquee, complete with a giant arrow, looks a bit like a budget version of the classic Holiday Inn signs from the 1960s. The colors may be a little more subdued, but there's no mistaking what inspired it. It was built to catch the eye of motorists, and it still does a pretty good job of that today.
The motel sits along historic U.S. Route 40, one of America's oldest cross-country highways. When this place was new, West Broad Street was lined with businesses competing for the attention of travelers, and a sign like this helped set the motel apart. Vintage postcards proudly advertised air conditioning, free television, telephones, tile bathrooms, and even a Salesman's Lounge—exactly the kind of comforts road trippers were looking for during the golden age of highway travel.
The sign has become just as well known for its reader board as its size. Over the years, it has displayed a steady stream of funny and thought-provoking messages that have become a favorite with locals. Movie fans may even recognize the marquee from the 2004 television adaptation of A Wrinkle in Time, where it appeared as the "It Motel" sign. Between its unique design, giant arrow, and ever-changing messages, it's easy to see why this is one of Columbus's best-known roadside signs.
40 Motel sign close-up
Columbus, OH Photo courtesy Sol Bermann
UPDATE: The 40 Motel is still open today, and its giant roadside marquee continues to stand along historic U.S. Route 40. It's one of the last great motel signs left in Columbus and thankfully still welcomes travelers today. 07-26
Here's a close-up look at the 40 Motel sign. It's good to see that there are still existing roadside signs along the old Highway 40 as it cut through Columbus. 05-06
Arrowhead Motel (Gone)
Wisconsin Dells, WI Photo courtesy Don Gardner
Here are a couple of motels named the Arrowhead Motel. The Wisconsin Dells version was in fantastic shape when this photo was taken, and the colorful marquee appears to be made of porcelain enamel. With its bright colors and bold design, it probably looked even better when the neon was glowing after dark.
The Arrowhead Motel was one of many independent motels that welcomed vacationers visiting Wisconsin Dells during the highway travel boom. While plenty of motels came and went over the years, this one stood out thanks to its eye-catching sign. Sometimes a great marquee is all it takes to make a place memorable, and this one certainly did its job.
The motel was operated for many years by John and Loretta Halcarz, who purchased the property in 1969 after moving from Chicago. They ran the motel for two decades before it eventually changed hands and took on a different purpose.
UPDATE: The Arrowhead Motel is no longer operating as a motel. The property has been repurposed, and while the original sign structure is still standing, it has been heavily altered. The colorful porcelain finish has been painted over, and much of the original marquee has been replaced, making it a shadow of what it once was. 07-26
Star Motel (Demolished)
Wisconsin Dells, WI Photo courtesy Don Gardner
The Star Motel in Wisconsin Dells has a sign that looks an awful lot like the classic Holiday Inn marquee from the 1960s. Whether it was meant as a tribute or simply inspired by the famous design, it's hard not to notice the resemblance. For an independent motel, borrowing a little style from one of the biggest names in roadside lodging probably wasn't a bad idea.
During the 1960s and 1970s, quite a few independent motels put up signs that echoed the look of Holiday Inn's famous "Great Sign." The Star Motel was one of them, giving passing motorists something familiar to spot along the busy Wisconsin Dells Parkway. Even if it wasn't an original, it still had plenty of roadside appeal and fit right in with the colorful motel strip.
UPDATE: The Star Motel is gone as an independent motel after becoming part of the Mt. Olympus resort complex. The old Holiday Inn-style sign was removed during the conversion, and the property now operates as Mykonos Village. It's a shame the sign didn't survive. 07-26
Shelton Inn (Demolished)
Peru, IN Photo courtesy Emily Steele
This motel in Peru still features its distinctive sloping roof and advertises itself with a sign built right into the rooftop. Shelton Inn didn't need a towering roadside marquee to get noticed. The unique roofline and rooftop sign gave it plenty of character all on their own.
Located along the old Business U.S. 31 corridor through town, the Shelton Inn welcomed travelers looking for a convenient place to spend the night. The steep roof made it stand out from the typical roadside motels of the era, and it's easy to see why it caught Emily Steele's attention. Sometimes it's the simple architectural touches that make a motel memorable.
UPDATE: Unfortunately, the Shelton Inn is no longer around. The motel has been demolished, and the rooftop sign disappeared along with the building. Today the site is an empty lot, leaving this photo as a reminder of another small roadside motel that's been lost. 07-26
Overpass
Motel
Winchester, IN Photo courtesy Steve Felder
The Overpass Motel sign is lighting up for another evening in Winchester, Indiana. At U.S. 27 and State Road 32, the glowing marquee gives passing travelers a familiar roadside welcome. It’s good to find an old sign still earning its keep after dark.
Kenneth and Doris Girton owned and operated the motel for many years. When a modern hotel opened next door in 2007, the original drive-up rooms stayed in service, giving guests a choice between newer accommodations and the classic motor court. Fortunately, expansion didn’t mean sending the older buildings to the wrecking ball.
UPDATE: The original motel has continued operating alongside its newer neighbor, with the vintage sign remaining part of the property. Its glowing marquee keeps a little of the old highway atmosphere alive at this Winchester crossroads. 07-26